- This topic has 4 replies, 1 voice, and was last updated 11 months ago by Mischievous Thwapling.
June 10, 2020 at 3:50 pm #50145Kylie WingfeatherGuest
So, I thought it would be fun if we have a a place to discuss what if’s. Such as what if Nugget hadn’t died? Would he have traveled across The Dark Sea of Darkness with them? If so, what do you think the people of the Green Hollows would have thought of him? Would they have been scared of him, or curious? And would Leeli still have gotten Baxter?
- This topic was modified 11 months ago by Madame Sidler.
June 10, 2020 at 5:10 pm #50148Mischievous ThwaplingGuest
Oooo, I love this idea!
I don’t know if Nugget would have been able to fit in the tunnel/boggan (it is called a boggan, right?) that took them to the ship, which, of course, sailed them to the Green Hollows. If he did, I think the Green Hollows folk probably would’ve at least a little apprehensive of him. After all, he is a GIANT dog!
Wasn’t Baxter given to Leeli partly because of Nugget’s death? I think she still might have gotten him, but I’m not sure.
Here’s a what if: (potential spoiler)
What if Artham never left Esben?
June 10, 2020 at 5:43 pm #50153Wingiby IggibyGuest
Nugget! *takes break to sob heart out in another room* We have decided, that if we get another dog, he is going to be named Nugget!
I wish he hadn’t died, and thought about it a little. It would have changed the whole dynamic of the books. The Stranders would have acted differently, and Nugget couldn’t have fit in the burrow. But he would have helped a lot in the trip to Kimera. And yeah, the Hollowsfolk would have been a little, well, you know what I mean.
Artham and Esben. A lot would have been changed. Artham probably would have been melded, and therefore wreaked havoc on Aerwiar, unless he became a cloven instead (which is very likely considering the state Esben was in). The children would have been carted off to Gnag, and the story would have concluded a lot sooner. Artham may have been a minor character, but the Saga couldn’t have survived without him!
June 10, 2020 at 7:35 pm #50161Kylie WingfeatherGuest
Ok. What if Janner had a twin sister. How would that have changed the story? I asked A.P. on Questions for Mr. Peterson if a Throne Warden had a twin would they would share the role, but no answer yet, so I’m going to assume that they would have the same position.
June 10, 2020 at 9:05 pm #50164Mischievous ThwaplingGuest
If Janner had a twin sister, a lot probably would have been different. Would she have stopped Kalmar from running away, therefore he would’ve never been fanged, or, would she have gone gone to the fork factory with Janner? The ending of the Wingfeather saga might have been different too…
- The forum ‘The Saga: Books 1-4’ is closed to new topics and replies.